(no subject)
14 Dec 2005 07:46 pmi feel like coming out as a detester of crackfic. it's somewhat ironic, actually, because i often enjoy badfic and read it for amusement. and i've always liked crackfic before. i enjoy it as crack and not as normal fic, but in general i've been fine with that. what's been making me cranky lately is that i prefer real fic, dammit, and the ratio of crack:real is getting too high for me. now i can't enjoy the crack properly because it's just boring by comparison to the real fic which i can wistfully imagine enjoying.
i'm mostly talking about sga fandom, here, which is the one i'm principally involved in. and my preferences are different in every fandom, so it's not like i've actually gone off crackfic as a whole. but wow, am i past fed up with it here.
it may be that there's something specific about the canon that lowers my crack tolerance. as i said, my preferences are different in every fandom. i wonder if it has something to do with the hefty dose of fantasy that's already inherent in a canon that's stuffed with star trek-esque pseudoscience and has a very deep fount of potential deus ex machinae in the form of the ancients. i love my pseudoscience and the mixture of fantasy and hard sf elements and the cynical contemporary reactions of the main characters when they're stuffed into these plots and situations. i'm right there with everyone else on the coolness of the fact that, with this canon, you can believably pull off almost anything. perhaps what makes it especially annoying in this fandom is that going even beyond canon's levels of improbability seems, to me... unnecessarily greedy. i mean, it's so improbable already--can it be that your thirst for the improbable (or your reliance on the large wiggle room provided by the expansion of probability) is so great that the quantity of it in canon doesn't satisfy you?
i'm mostly talking about sga fandom, here, which is the one i'm principally involved in. and my preferences are different in every fandom, so it's not like i've actually gone off crackfic as a whole. but wow, am i past fed up with it here.
it may be that there's something specific about the canon that lowers my crack tolerance. as i said, my preferences are different in every fandom. i wonder if it has something to do with the hefty dose of fantasy that's already inherent in a canon that's stuffed with star trek-esque pseudoscience and has a very deep fount of potential deus ex machinae in the form of the ancients. i love my pseudoscience and the mixture of fantasy and hard sf elements and the cynical contemporary reactions of the main characters when they're stuffed into these plots and situations. i'm right there with everyone else on the coolness of the fact that, with this canon, you can believably pull off almost anything. perhaps what makes it especially annoying in this fandom is that going even beyond canon's levels of improbability seems, to me... unnecessarily greedy. i mean, it's so improbable already--can it be that your thirst for the improbable (or your reliance on the large wiggle room provided by the expansion of probability) is so great that the quantity of it in canon doesn't satisfy you?