cimorene

So what happened was that my cousin is getting married in just over 1 month and I went to her wedding website to RSVP. And got side-tracked by the picture on the front page.

me: OMG! HE LOOKS EXACTLY LIKE ONE OF THOSE GUYS!
wax: YES! He looks like that... GUY... who has a brother! You know, the brother was in that episode of... one of the shows that we watch! And the guy was also but in another show!
me: Uh...?
wax: It's coming to me! The brother was also in... like... not NCIS! But the other one... the one with Reid! Oh! And the guy, he was also on - one of our - OH! And he used to be on The Daily Show! AND HIS NAME HAS LIKE R-T-R IN IT!

So then I looked up The Daily Show on IMDb and solved the whole question.