Oh no

22 Jan 2024 10:04 am
cimorene: A drawing of a person in red leaving a line of blue footprints in white snow (winter)
Was reading some Hugos controversy (...) and I kept seeing Bluesky mentioned a lot, so I finally looked it up on Wikipedia. And oh no, that looks like a terrible idea... the same people who were behind Twitter enshittification?!

I saw someone say they were so tired of social platforms funded by venture capital, and I really feel that, but the alternatives seem to be DW and mastodon. I guess I need to investigate the latter again, which I've been meaning to get around to for at least a couple of years now.

It feels like using DW for everything might be nicer, but then I definitely do understand the benefit of having a shorter form alternative.
cimorene: minimal cartoon stick figure on the phone to the Ikea store, smiling in relief (call ikea)
I did check it and skim through it, but I don't have a way to more thoroughly check.

Oh dear.

10 Nov 2022 09:10 pm
cimorene: cartoon woman with short bobbed hair wearing bubble-top retrofuturistic space suit in front of purple starscape (intrepid)
Earlier this week I was still thinking there was no point in backing up my Twitter yet since they were probably overrun in server requests for these backups and it's not like it was going to disappear overnight; the kind of failures people are predicting here take time to happen.

But I decided to go ahead and request an archive of my tweets anyway. I guess I might as well get in the queue in case employees have to handle them directly. I don't want them all to leave before somebody sends me my tweets.

I've been meaning to get around to checking out mastodon and those fannish attempts at user-hosted social media for... years... I'm not great at getting around to stuff.
cimorene: painting of a glowering woman pouring a thin stream of glowing green liquid from an enormous bowl (misanthropy)
It's not just that images of text are useless for screenreaders, it's also that a huge amount of posts that have no real (or literally no) non-text content are couched in images for no good reason. There's so MUCH of it and they're inconvenient for far more people than just people with screenreaders!

  • screengrabs of things like tweets, or worse, screengrabs of long tweet threads that take a whole bunch of phone screenshots

  • screenshots of things that aren't tweets where even the image, when viewed actual size, is not actually legible due to the colors and fonts and sizes

  • text advice made into comics except it's not actually converted to a comic, it's just handwritten and spread around with a lot of white space and then illustrated a bit, but the illustrations don't really add much of anything and the white space makes the whole thing take up three or four screens of scrolling, while the handwriting is considerably less legible and the white space makes you skip around to read so that it's considerably less readable than a few simple lines of text

  • long comics that have actually been made into comics and the point is in dialogue and drawings, but again, they take pages and pages and the art isn't anything special, so that there's no plausible benefit to it being a comic unless they're like trying to trick people who refuse to read information in paragraphs I guess, but like, you're on a blog platform with tons of information in paragraphs anyway?


Just a lot of baffling, seemingly thoughtless inconvenience. Sure, the readers can just choose not to read stuff in horrible formats, which sort of solves the problem at their end (provided they have a way to browse social media that hides excess length posts behind a cut tag), but then that interaction still represents a failure of communication. And if the posters somehow don't consider it a failure of communication - if they're just like "It doesn't bother me at all one way or another whether people read this!" - then they've spent a surprising amount of time posting it, haven't they?

There's a slight exemption for comics people, who conceivably could be interested purely in a demographic of other comics people who prefer to read in a comic format no matter what. I might doubt how much a comic fan gets out of some that seem to me to be barely comics, but I'm clearly not in that bracket so I shouldn't expect to get it.

What if there was an extension that could just completely hide any social media post that was text in an image? I can only dream.
cimorene: cartoony drawing of a woman's head in profile giving dubious side-eye (glasses)
I've seen analytical comments on Twitter and Tumblr referring to the posting style of "Buckle Up Twitter", but I wonder what would be the appropriate term for the rhetorical style itself (that is to say, the rhythm/pacing and melody, the frequent borrowing of clickbait framing/listicle style, the didacticism, and the heightened sense of urgency combined with a self-consciously artificial, vague chumminess - an assumption of familiarity that also makes clear we all understand the audience is actually strangers).

I am not sure if my perception is accurate (because Recency Illusion), but I have a sense that I'm seeing this rhetorical style being used gradually further and further from Buckle Up Twitter-style subject matter (ie less arguably urgent or important).
cimorene: cartoony drawing of a woman's head in profile giving dubious side-eye (Default)
A couple of days after the US election, I started following every link from a political retweeter that said anything about someone else I should follow. I didn't subscribe to absolutely all of the accounts, but I did end up following a number of journalists, activists, historians and other scholars and experts in fascism, religious authoritarianism, kleptocracy, Russia, and US politics. And also a few focused on global warming and carbon tax.

The result made my timeline so high-volume that I rarely actually manage to backread the whole thing anymore, and I had to create separate lists for Serious and Fun/Fannish stuff. Here's my 14-member Anti-Fascist Twitter feed, which (kind of sadly) updates way way faster than my personal fannish list.

I've also had an increasing number of complete strangers follow me since I started all the political retweeting - complete strangers with primarily political interest it seems, I mean. I'm not exactly comfortable with that, but I think it's too late to really do anything. I could protect my account, but that seems silly, because the stuff isn't exactly private or worthy of keeping secret, just... I never really had to worry about anyone being interested enough to accidentally see it before?

I could make a separate Twitter account for that stuff, but a) it's a bit late because I already have all these complete strangers following my personal one with its tweets about fanfiction and hockey gay porn jokes??? and b) I kind of resist doing that, not philosophically, exactly, just... kinda worried it would be too fiddly and I'd end up messing it up.

But my main concern with that is that I don't have any sort of expertise, unlike pretty much every account on that list above, and I'm also not producing any original content to speak of, so... ? I'm not even attempting to exercise any sort of expertise at curation of retweets, not that I'm claiming to have any in the first place. I have tweeted suggestions of experts to follow a couple of times, but reiterating it regularly would get pretty tiresome so I have restrained myself.

So in the meantime I just kind of hang out here, remaining uncomfortable every time I get a new couple of follow notifications.
cimorene: cartoony drawing of a woman's head in profile giving dubious side-eye (stfu)
Yet another thought that I only realized after the fact was too long for Twitter


(3:04) Posting on DW feels so weird and artificial when I'm used to Twitter and Tumblr.

(3:05) It feels like making an Event out of what seems like just more of the same disconnected babble that is always in my head.

(3:06) Like in order to qualify for a Blog Entry, it should be a position piece, or a reminiscence, not just 20x too long for Twitter.

(3:06) But I can't start posting these things on Tumblr, because Tumblr is like 98:2 noise: signal and the tagging system is shit.

(3:07) ... Not to mention the COMMENTING system, geez. I am not comfortable having personal interactions or conversations there. Awkward & weird.

These tweets on Storify



The gap between Twitter, Tumblr, and DW is long stuff that doesn't seem all that important but which you nonetheless might want comments on and/or would like indexed and taggable.

...

Dreamwidth's (or rather, LJ-style) calendar-based archive browsing, the ability to bundle and rename tags and to label memories, and the nested commenting and notification/tracking features on DW are too useful to me as a blog owner to just abandon.

And for fandom purposes, LJ-style comment pages, notification and tracking features, and the community concept are similarly indispensible, until we get another good non-instantaneous mailing list/messageboard substitue.

But the filtering functionality you can get on Tumblr with Xkit or even just Tumblr savior, not to mention the ease of posting and embedding media and the reblog+comment concept, are still irresistable - and that doesn't even touch on the ability to search and browse across the site by tags, which is a huge boon to fandom.



What would the ideal solution have to look like, anyway? What do I even want? )

Profile

cimorene: cartoony drawing of a woman's head in profile giving dubious side-eye (Default)
Cimorene

June 2025

S M T W T F S
12 3 4 5 67
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930     

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

  • Style: Practically Dracula for Practicalitesque - Practicality (with tweaks) by [personal profile] cimorene
  • Resources: Dracula Theme

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated 8 Jun 2025 08:27 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios